1905 1 4 Unknown
1906 1 3 1 George Peach
1907 4 2 William Evans
1908 2 3 C.H.H. Branch
1909 6 2 1 Charles Meacham
1910 2 4 Charles Meacham
1911 5 2 1 Andrew Powell
1912 6 1 Dan Blake
1913 5 3 Andrew Powell
1914 7 1 William Whitnell
1915 4 5 Ernest Mallary
1916 5 3 Ernest Mallary
1917 5 1 O.V. Petty
1918 0 1 Unknown
1919 7 2 Osborne Radford
1920 7 0 1 Marvin Eagle
1921 6 2 Marvin Eagle
1922 3 3 2 Clarence Clark
1923 1 6 John Keek
1924 2 3 3 Guy Rice
1925 7 1 1 Guy Rice
1926 8 0 1 Henry Lyon
1927 7 1 Henry Lyon
1928 8 0 1 Henry Lyon
1929 2 6 Oakley Brown
1930 5 3 1 Oakley Brown
1931 7 2 1 Ralph McRight
1932 1 8 Ralph McRight
1933 3 7 Ralph McRight
1934 7 2 Ralph McRight
1935 6 3 1 Ralph McRight
1936 7 2 1 Ralph McRight
1937 1 7 2 Ralph Mills
1938 8 1 1 Ralph Mills
1939 7 4 Ralph Mills
1940 11 0 Ralph Mills
1941 11 1 Ralph Mills
1942 6 4 1 Oakley Brown
1943 10 0 Oakley Brown
1944 9 1 Chris Cox
1945 8 2 Ralph Mills
1946 5 5 1 Ralph Mills
1947 6 5 Ralph Mills
1948 6 5 Ralph Mills
1949 6 5 Howard Moss
1950 2 9 Howard Moss
1951 2 8 1 Howard Moss
1952 3 7 1 Patrick McNeil
1953 7 4 Patrick McNeil
1954 3 6 2 Patrick McNeil
1955 5 6 James Bravard
1956 7 4 James Bravard
1957 7 2 James Bravard
1958 7 3 James Bravard
1959 6 4 James Bravard
1960 3 5 1 James Bravard
1961 2 6 1 James Bravard
1962 10 1 Fleming Thornton
1963 7 3 Fleming Thornton
1964 9 2 Fleming Thornton
1965 14 0 Fleming Thornton
1966 13 0 Fleming Thornton
1967 2 6 2 Fleming Thornton
1968 5 3 3 Fleming Thornton
1969 3 7 Fleming Thornton
1970 5 6 Fleming Thornton
1971 9 2 1 Fleming Thornton
1972 9 3 Fleming Thornton
1973 7 4 Fleming Thornton
1974 7 3 1 Fleming Thornton
1975 7 4 Fleming Thornton
1976 2 8 Fleming Thornton
1977 2 9 Daniel Sundberg
1978 3 8 Daniel Sundberg
1979 5 4 Daniel Sundberg
1980 3 7 Daniel Sundberg
1981 3 8 Mike Lewis
1982 4 6 Mike Lewis
1983 8 3 Mike Lewis
1984 9 4 Mike Lewis
1985 7 3 Mike Lewis
1986 3 7 Craig Clayton
1987 6 4 Craig Clayton
1988 8 4 Craig Clayton
1989 8 3 Craig Clayton
1990 3 8 Craig Clayton
1991 5 6 Craig Clayton
1992 7 4 Craig Clayton
1993 6 4 Craig Clayton
1994 8 4 Craig Clayton
1995 12 1 Craig Clayton
1996 13 2 Craig Clayton
1997 13 2 Craig Clayton* (Officially 0-13 due to playing inelegible player)
1998 5 6 Craig Clayton
1999 12 2 Craig Clayton
2000 10 4 Craig Clayton
2001 12 2 Craig Clayton
2002 10 4 Craig Clayton
2003 8 5 Craig Clayton
2004 13 1 Craig Clayton
2005 9 4 Dixie Jones
2006 7 6 Dixie Jones
2007 4 7 Dixie Jones
2008 7 5 Dixie Jones
2009 3 8 Dixie Jones